There are many types of medical cervical collars, including the Philadelphia cervical collar, soft cervical collar, and inflatable collar. This article mainly discusses the differences between the Philadelphia cervical collar and the soft cervical collar, giving a detailed introduction to their materials, functions, and usage scenarios. This information aims to help you choose the right collar for your specific symptoms.
The Philadelphia cervical collar (also called the split collar or polymer collar) is made of special materials such as polyethylene foam combined with rigid plastic, providing both softness and comfort as well as firm support. It features a two-piece design—front and back panels—which are joined and fixed using Velcro, allowing for adjustable tightness and fitting various neck sizes. The Philadelphia cervical collar is also designed for breathability; the front panel has an opening for tracheal intubation (for medical procedures), and there are ventilation holes all around to reduce stuffiness.
The soft cervical collar, also known as the foam collar, is a medical orthotic device made of soft materials like felt or high-density foam. It is wrapped with breathable cotton fabric, balancing support with wearing comfort. The typical design is lower in the front and higher in the back: the lower, curved front pad fits the contour of the chin to support the jaw and gently flex the head forward. The rear extends to the level of the occipital bone, providing a reminder to avoid tilting the head backward and limiting neck overextension.
The Philadelphia cervical collar provides cervical support and stability, helps reduce the load of the head on the cervical spine, and alleviates symptoms such as cervical spondylosis, stiff neck, and disc herniation. It also restricts excessive flexion and extension of the neck, preventing over-bending or overextension, and is suitable for postoperative recovery, cervical kyphosis, stable cervical fractures, and ligament injuries. Its material design combines comfort and durability, with polymer foam and rigid plastics, featuring ventilation holes and a split structure to ensure breathability and stability during use.
The soft cervical collar(foam collar)can restrict excessive movement of the cervical spine, prevent neck hyperextension, and reduce joint pressure and nerve abrasion. In addition, it can decrease muscle tension, share the load of the head, reduce neck muscle strain, and relieve chronic fatigue or muscle spasms and stiffness caused by a stiff neck. It improves local circulation, reduces abnormal pressure on nerves and blood vessels, and helps resolve tissue swelling. The soft cervical collar is mainly used for mild cases and as auxiliary treatment. It is suitable for people who lower their heads for extended periods (such as office workers and drivers) to prevent cervical fatigue and strain. It also provides temporary support and pain relief for mild cervical spondylosis, neck muscle strain, or stiff neck.
The Philadelphia cervical collar is primarily used in three scenarios:
Cervical trauma and postoperative recovery: It provides external support for stable or slightly displaced fractures to prevent secondary injury. It can also be used for post-repositioning fixation (such as atlantoaxial subluxation) and transitional fixation after cervical fracture or dislocation surgery.
Some degenerative cervical conditions: During the acute phase of radiculopathic cervical spondylosis, wearing a Philadelphia cervical collar can relieve pain and numbness caused by nerve compression. For disc herniation or cervical kyphosis, it restricts abnormal motion and reduces inflammation.
Emergency and temporary immobilization: The Philadelphia cervical collar is used for immediate cervical immobilization at the scene of trauma—such as car accidents or falls—to prevent further injury during transportation. It can also be used with a stretcher for patient transfer to ensure spinal stability.
The soft cervical collar is mainly suitable for mild-to-moderate cervical problems, such as chronic neck pain, early-stage cervical spondylosis, soft tissue injuries of the neck (non-fracture/dislocation), or the rehabilitation transition period. It can also be used in the early postoperative phase or after traction therapy as a transitional tool for stability training. Other scenarios include long-distance driving or desk work that require temporary cervical immobilization.
In summary, these are the basic differences between the Philadelphia cervical collar and the soft cervical collar. If you have cervical problems, please seek medical attention promptly and follow your doctor’s advice.
Our company primarily produces and wholesales various types of medical fixation belts and external fixation devices. The medical fixation belts include multi-headed abdominal belts, multi-headed chest belts, ostomy abdominal belts, fully elastic waist belts, fully elastic waist support (wide), wrist fixation belts, knee fixation belts, , among others. The medical external fixation devices include neck braces, head-neck-trunk fixation devices, shoulder abduction fixation devices, thoracolumbar fixation devices, adjustable knee joint fixation devices and knee-ankle-foot orthoses, etc.